27 February 2003


Inter-American Court of Human Rights to hear criminal defamation case

Incident details

Mauricio Herrera Ulloa

This is available in:

English Español

(CPJ/IFEX) - The following is a 26 February 2003 CPJ press release:

COSTA RICA: Inter-American Court to hear criminal defamation case

New York, February 26, 2003 - The Inter-American Court of Human Rights said last week that it will hear the case of Costa Rican journalist Mauricio Herrera Ulloa, who was convicted of criminal defamation in 1999. A ruling could set a precedent to determine whether criminal defamation is permissible under international law.

On February 3, the Washington, D.C.-based Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (IACHR) submitted the case to the court, asking for the dismissal of the sentence against Herrera Ulloa on the grounds that it violates the journalist's right to freedom of expression, as established by the American Convention on Human Rights.

Decisions of the Inter-American Court are legally binding on the countries that have accepted the court's jurisdiction, including Costa Rica. Both the commission and the court are entities of the Organization of American States.

"This is an extremely significant development with far-reaching legal implications," said CPJ acting director Joel Simon. "We are glad that the IACHR submitted the case to the Inter-American Court, and we hope that any ruling will set a positive precedent for other criminal defamation cases in the region."

On November 12, 1999, the Penal Court of the First Judicial Circuit in Costa Rica's capital, San José, convicted Herrera Ulloa and the San José daily La Nacion of criminal defamation. The case was based on 1995 articles by Herrera Ulloa that cited European press reports alleging corruption by former Costa Rican diplomat Félix Przedborski.

The Penal Court ordered Herrera Ulloa to pay Przedborski damages equivalent to 120 days' wages. It also ruled that the journalist's name be inscribed in an official list of convicted criminals. La Nacion was ordered to pay the plaintiff's legal fees and 60 million colones (US$200,000) in damages; to publish the ruling; and to remove all links from its Web site that could lead readers to the offending articles.

After the Costa Rican Supreme Court rejected La Nacion's appeal on January 2001, the newspaper and the journalist filed a petition with the IACHR. In September 2001, at the request of the IACHR, the Inter-American Court issued "provisional measures" ordering Costa Rican authorities to suspend certain sections of the verdict against Herrera Ulloa and La Nacion.

Last week, on February 17, 2003, the Inter-American Court notified the IACHR that it would hear the case. According to the IACHR, the penalties against Herrera Ulloa are excessive, disproportionate, and have a chilling effect on "the dissemination of information over matters of interest involving public officials." The IACHR also requested that the Inter-American Court order Costa Rica to bring its legislation regarding criminal defamation in line with international standards.

CPJ is a New York-based, independent, nonprofit organization that works to safeguard press freedom worldwide. For more information about press conditions in Costa Rica, visit www.cpj.org">http://www.cpj.org">www.cpj.org


Committee to Protect Journalists
330 7th Ave., 11th Floor
New York, NY 10001
info (@) cpj.org
Fax:+1 212 4659568
Costa Rica

IFEX members working in this country 1

More from Costa Rica
  • Freedom of the Press 2016: Costa Rica

  • Freedom of the Press 2014: Costa Rica

    Ranked 22nd in annual global media freedom report

  • Freedom in the World 2014: Costa Rica

    Journalists no longer face imprisonment for releasing secret political information following revision of controversial 2012 law