5 January 2012


National Court of Justice ratifies three-year prison sentence against Emilio Palacio

Incident details

Appeal rejected

Emilio Palacio, Editor

This is available in:

English Español
(Fundamedios/IFEX) - 29 December 2011 - The Second Criminal Division of the National Court of Justice issued a ruling yesterday rejecting an appeal for review of the case submitted by Emilio Palacio, former opinion editor of the newspaper "El Universo". The court also set the date of Friday 13 January 2012 for a public hearing during which the counsel for the newspaper and the paper's directors can present their arguments for appealing the case on legal grounds.

The members of the Second Criminal Division deemed that the appeal for review of the case presented by Palacio, after his appeal on legal grounds was rejected in September, was "unfounded". As a result, the judges rejected the appeal and imposed a fine amounting to three minimum living wages (US$792). In effect, they ratified the sentence issued against Palacio by a first instance court and upheld by a second instance court in the defamation trial launched by the president of the republic, Rafael Correa.

Palacio told Fundamedios that the ruling did not come as a surprise. "If it was not this way, they would have found another way to condemn me following another illegal and immoral path . . . this court has remained silent about all the infringements of the law that have taken place in the country," the former editor said.

José Alvear, Palacio's lawyer, told the press that the decision is illegal because there was no hearing to consider the appeal for review of the case.

On 6 February 2011, Palacio published an opinion article entitled "No a las mentiras". This resulted in a lawsuit against "El Universo", and eventually temporary judge Juan Paredes sentenced the former editor and the paper's directors, Carlos, César and Nicolás Perez, to three years in prison and the payment of US$40 million in damages.

The sentence has been questioned by several individuals because of the speed at which it was issued, within less than 24 hours, during which time Paredes would have had to read all the documentation concerning the case and draft a 156-page ruling between the evening of 19 July and the early hours of the next day.

Because of this the Guayas Prosecutor's Office initiated an investigation of the judge, for the alleged crime of malfeasance and moral turpitude, that is, issuing a resolution with the knowledge that it is unjustified, assuming responsibilities that do not concern him and determining that certain falsified events were true.


Putting free expression issues in perspective.

Sign up to receive IFEX In Context.

More from Ecuador
  • The U-turn: Moreno steers Ecuador away from Correa's media repression

    Journalists say they will be wary until Moreno fulfills his promises to scale back the Communications Law and scrap the regulator that enforced it.

  • Freedom on the Net 2017: Ecuador

    Politically motivated takedown requests for alleged copyright violations targeted online news outlets and the websites of human rights organizations

  • Freedom of the Press 2016: Ecuador

    Since its establishment under the 2013 Communications Law, Ecuador’s media regulator, known as SUPERCOM, has issued sanctions in more than 300 cases against media outlets.

At this point, would publish: "Home page"
At this point, would publish: "IFEX members urge President to withdraw US$80 million lawsuit against paper"
At this point, would publish: "Government media outlets attempt to link founder and owner of newspaper to corrupt businesses"
At this point, would publish: "President requests more than 150 reports about directors and feature writer in connection with lawsuit against newspaper"
At this point, would publish: "Columnist resigns in attempt to stop president's lawsuit against paper"
At this point, would publish: "Newspaper directors, writer sentenced to three years in prison, US$40 million fine"
At this point, would publish: "Cyber activists hack municipality's webpage in protest against government's attacks on free expression"
At this point, would publish: "Defence lawyers question judge's independence in case against newspaper; opinion editor faces new lawsuit"
At this point, would publish: "Faced with ongoing legal action, journalist decides to leave the country"
At this point, would publish: "President's attorney asks public prosecutor to initiate additional legal action against "El Universo" newspaper"
At this point, would publish: "Tribunal upholds sentencing of newspaper, its directors and former feature writer on defamation charge"
At this point, would publish: ""El Universo" threatened with two more lawsuits"
At this point, would publish: "Former columnist faces second lawsuit for slander"
At this point, would publish: "Se denuncia que sentencia contra diario fue elaborada por abogados del presidente de la república"
At this point, would publish: "President demands US$80 million in case against newspaper, directors and feature writer"
IFEX is a global network of committed organisations working to defend and promote free expression.
Permission is granted for material on this website to be reproduced or republished in whole or in part provided the source member and/or IFEX is cited with a link to the original item.