24 February 2006


Belarusian and Indian authorities launch criminal actions over cartoon furor

Incident details

Aleksei Korol, Aleksandr Sdvizhkov, Alok Tomar

(CPJ/IFEX) - The following is a CPJ press release:

Cartoon furor becomes press freedom crisis
In Belarus and India, governments launch criminal actions

New York, February 23, 2006 - Controversy over the publication of drawings of the Prophet Muhammed continued to grow as an international press freedom crisis on Thursday as Indian authorities imprisoned a magazine editor and Belarusian prosecutors opened a criminal probe into a weekly newspaper. In each case, the publications said they printed one or more cartoons to provide context for the worldwide furor that has now claimed at least 48 lives.

At least nine countries worldwide have now taken punitive actions against publications or their editors for reprinting one or more of the 12 depictions first published last year by a Danish newspaper, according to research compiled by the Committee to Protect Journalists. Six newspapers in three countries have been forced to close and at least nine journalists in four countries have been arrested and face potential criminal prosecution. Governments have also issued censorship orders and sponsored protests.

In Belarus, the state prosecutor's office is investigating potential charges of inciting religious hatred against the independent weekly Zgoda after the newspaper reprinted eight of the 12 Danish drawings of the Prophet Muhammad on February 17. The drawings ran alongside an article headlined "Political Creation," which chronicled the uproar caused by the cartoons. The Belarusian Security Service (KGB) is conducting the probe, Zgoda Editor-in-Chief Aleksei Korol told CPJ in a telephone interview today.

KGB agents searched Korol's Minsk apartment, which also serves as the weekly's headquarters, on Wednesday, questioning him and his deputy, Aleksandr Sdvizhkov, for two hours, he said. Agents confiscated the paper's four computers, computer discs, and other electronic equipment, Korol said. The editors have not been formally charged, Korol told CPJ.

The probe was begun after authorities received complaints from the state Committee for Religious and Ethnic Affairs on behalf of the small Muslim community in Belarus, according to local press reports.

Korol said he believes the government will use the case as a pretext to close his 5,000-circulation newspaper, one of the few sources of independent news in the tightly controlled country. Zgoda has covered the presidential election campaign of opposition candidate Aleksandr Kozulin, a rival to incumbent Aleksandr Lukashenko who is seeking a third term on March 19. State media, which dominate the press landscape, have not covered the opposition.

Information Minister Vladimir Rusakevich told the news agency Interfax later today that the ministry plans to suspend Zgoda for three months for republishing the cartoons, and proceed to seek the paper's permanent closure in court.

In New Delhi, India, police arrested Alok Tomar, editor of the Hindi-language magazine Shabdarth, after receiving a complaint that a cartoon of the prophet had appeared in the magazine. Indian media reports say New Delhi police also confiscated several hundred copies of the magazine and ordered police in other states to seize all copies of the magazine too.

According to Tomar's colleagues quoted in media reports, one cartoon was reprinted in Shabdarth to accompany an article that criticized the original publication of the drawings. No formal charge against Tomar was publicly disclosed, but the editor remained in jail as of Thursday.

Tomar's associates insisted the magazine, which isn't widely circulated, had no intention to offend Muslims. The cartoon was reprinted to support an article that, on the contrary, argued the media should refrain from criticizing religious practices, journalist Sapnendra Sinha told The Associated Press.

"While we recognize the many deeply held views, we are alarmed that countries around the world are using this issue as pretext for closing independent publications and silencing critical voices," CPJ Executive Director Ann Cooper said.

Today, CPJ sent letters to heads of state in Algeria, Yemen and Jordan, protesting the arrests of journalists in those countries. Read the letters:

* To Jordan: http://www.cpj.org/protests/06ltrs/mideast/jordan23feb06pl.html
* To Yemen: http://www.cpj.org/protests/06ltrs/mideast/yemen23feb06pl.html
* To Algeria: http://www.cpj.org/protests/06ltrs/mideast/algeria23feb06pl.html
Here are earlier developments as reported by CPJ:

* In Denmark: http://www.cpj.org/news/2006/europe/denmark01feb06na.html
* In Jordan an South Africa: http://www.cpj.org/news/2006/mideast/jordan06feb06na.html
* In Yemen and Malaysia: http://www.cpj.org/news/2006/mideast/yemen09feb06na.html
* In Yemen and Algeria: http://www.cpj.org/news/2006/mideast/yemen14feb06na.html
* In Morocco: http://www.cpj.org/news/2006/mideast/morocco15feb06na.html
* In Russia: http://www.cpj.org/news/2006/europe/russia21feb06na.html
CPJ is a New York-based, independent, nonprofit organization that works to safeguard press freedom worldwide. For more information, visit http://www.cpj.org


Committee to Protect Journalists
330 7th Ave., 11th Floor
New York, NY 10001
info (@) cpj.org
Fax:+1 212 4659568

IFEX members working in this country 1

More from India
  • India: Pursuing truth in the face of intolerance

    PEN International's freedom of expression report on India

  • Freedom on the Net 2017: India

    The Supreme Court recognized privacy as a fundamental right in a landmark ruling in August 2017

  • Freedom of the Press 2017: India

    In May, the Supreme Court ruled to retain criminal defamation, despite calls for decriminalization.

More from Asia & Pacific


  • The Campaign for Justice: Press Freedom in South Asia 2013-14

    Journalism in South Asia is far from an easy profession, as the 12th annual review of journalism in the region "The Campaign for Justice: Press Freedom in South Asia 2013-14" portrays. But this year's report also tells the story of the courage of South Asia's journalists to defend press freedom and to ensure citizens' right to information and freedom of expression in the face of increasing challenges to the profession and personal safety.

  • THE STORIES WOMEN JOURNALISTS TELL: Women in Media in South Asia

    The report is the first created by the South Asia Media Solidarity Network (SAMSN) looking specifically at the experience of women journalists in the South Asia sub-region