3 November 2006


Five journalists injured, two others roughed up, in clashes with federal police in Oaxaca; investigators of Brad Will's murder slipping up, says RSF

Incident details

Brad Will, Jorge David Jaramillo Velásquez, Miguel Dimayuga, Germán Canseco, Jorge Brindis, Gilardo Mota, Mario Mosqueda Hernández, Alberto López Cruz

This is available in:

English Español
(RSF/IFEX) - While noting that two of Indymedia cameraman Brad Will's alleged killers were arrested and taken before a judge on 2 November 2006 in Oaxaca, RSF has condemned the shortcomings in the investigation into his fatal shooting and the fact that three others allegedly involved have been able to escape.

RSF also voiced outrage about the use of violence by the Federal Preventive Police (PFP) to disperse protesters in the past few days in Oaxaca, in the course of which five journalists were injured and two others were roughed up.

"Two of Will's alleged killers may well be under arrest but three others, including two municipal policemen and a paramilitary gang member, did not respond to a judicial summons and cannot be located," RSF said. "The investigation in no way absolves the Oaxaca state government of responsibility in Will's death and we reiterate our call for the creation of a federal commission of enquiry."

RSF added: "We also condemn the police brutality in which seven journalists were among the victims and we urge the federal authorities to punish those responsible."

The two men arrested yesterday on the orders of the Oaxaca state prosecutor's office for their alleged role in Will's murder were Abel Santiago Zárate, a local elected representative of the Institutional Revolutionary Party (PRI), to which Oaxaca State Governor Ulises Ruiz Ortiz belongs, and Zárate's chief bodyguard, Manuel Aguilar.

The national daily "Milenio" named the three other alleged killers who are now fugitives from justice as municipal policemen Carlos Soriano and Juan Carlos Sumano, and paramilitary gang member Pedro Carmona, who was identified by witnesses as the person who fired the shot that killed Will while he was covering a violent protest by teachers in Oaxaca on 27 October.

Yesterday's violence took place when the PFP federal police entered the Oaxaca university campus and dismantled barricades put up by the Popular Assembly of the Peoples of Oaxaca (APPO), which has been protesting for five months to press demands for the removal of Oaxaca's governor, Ruiz Ortiz.

Among the approximately 60 people injured in the violence were photographer Jorge David Jaramillo Velásquez of the "El Universal" daily, photographers Miguel Dimayuga and Germán Canseco of the weekly "Proceso" and cameraman Jorge Brindis of Canal 9 public television station, who were hit by flying glass or petrol bombs.

Jaramillo was hospitalised in serious condition, but his injuries are not life-threatening, RSF was told. Mario Mosqueda Hernández, a correspondent of the Centro de Medios Libres de México independent news agency, was beaten and dragged along the ground by 10 federal policemen during yesterday's incidents. He has injuries to the head, back and left arm.

Gilardo Mota of the local weekly "Opinión" told Agence France-Presse on 1 November that he was held for 48 hours and was roughed up by federal police officers after being arrested on 30 October while photographing police in action. He was finally released after paying bail of 3,000 pesos (approx. 216 euros). On 31 October, police attacked photographer Alberto López Cruz of the local daily "Extra" and took his camera. The Centro de Medios Libres de México also reported that two Guatemalan journalists went missing on 2 November.


Reporters Without Borders
47, rue Vivienne
75002 Paris
rsf (@) rsf.org
Fax:+33 1 45 23 11 51
More from Mexico
  • Freedom on the Net 2017: Mexico

    A series of revelations renewed concerns about illegal surveillance practices in the country, as spying software sold to the government abusively targeted human rights lawyers, journalists, and activists

  • Freedom of the Press 2017: Mexico

    Article 19, counted 11 murders of journalists in possible connection with their work for the year, and a total of 100 such killings since 2000.

  • Libertades de resistencia. Libertad de expresión y derecho a la información en México 2016

    Cuando hablamos de libertades en este in- forme no nos referimos solamente a valo- res abstractos que por lo general se nos ha dicho que debemos defender. Más bien, lo que narramos son historias de trabajo que se desenvuelven en el día a día y que están resistiendo a esas condiciones permanentes de marginación, opacidad y agresión.