11 January 2008


National human rights commission rules Guanajuato state official violated two newspaper's directors' freedom of expression

Incident details

Enrique Gómez Orozco, Arnoldo Cuéllar Ornelas


This is available in:

English Español
(CEPET/IFEX) - On 21 December 2007 the National Human Rights Commission (Comisión Nacional de Derechos Humanos, CNDH) recommended to Juan Manuel Oliva Ramírez, the governor of Guanajuato state, located in central Mexico, that an official of his administration offer a public apology to the directors of "a.m." and "Correo" newspapers for having violated their rights to freedom of expression, honour and good reputation. Oliva Ramírez belongs to the National Action Party (Partido Acción Nacional, PAN), the same party to which President Felipe Calderón belongs.

On 11 May, the secretary of the government, Gerardo Mosqueda Martínez, had made offensive comments, using damaging terms to refer to Enrique Gómez Orozco and Arnoldo Cuéllar Ornelas, the directors of "a.m." and "Correo" newspapers, respectively, during a public meeting with state and federal officials.

The CNDH subsequently recommended that Mosqueda Martínez apologise publicly and in writing. In a press conference on 21 July he said that he was apologizing, but made more offensive remarks and said he had received supportive telephone calls from many friends backing the opinions he had expressed in May, which had implied that the two newspaper directors were corrupt and otherwise lacking in ethics.

According to the CNDH ruling, Mosqueda Martínez's 21 July comments did not constitute the apology that it had recommended he make, but that he had instead principally focused on congratulating himself for having received support for his earlier comments.

This is not the first incident of this nature during Oliva Ramírez's term. The newpaper "a.m." publicly complained on 8 and 9 July that it was a victim of a government advertising boycott ordered by the governor himself. It stated, "never, since 'a.m.' was founded 29 years ago, has any government used public funds to pressure or punish the free expression of our ideas. Not even in the worst periods of the PRI's authoritarianism was there an attempt to pressure 'a.m.' in such a fashion." (see IFEX alert of 18 July 2007). The Institutional Revolutionary Party (El Partido Revolucionario Institutional, PRI) governed Mexico for 70 years.

Under the law, the governor has 15 business days to decide if he accepts the CNDH recommendation, and another 15 days to act on it.


More from Mexico
  • Freedom on the Net 2017: Mexico

    A series of revelations renewed concerns about illegal surveillance practices in the country, as spying software sold to the government abusively targeted human rights lawyers, journalists, and activists

  • Freedom of the Press 2017: Mexico

    Article 19, counted 11 murders of journalists in possible connection with their work for the year, and a total of 100 such killings since 2000.

  • Libertades de resistencia. Libertad de expresión y derecho a la información en México 2016

    Cuando hablamos de libertades en este in- forme no nos referimos solamente a valo- res abstractos que por lo general se nos ha dicho que debemos defender. Más bien, lo que narramos son historias de trabajo que se desenvuelven en el día a día y que están resistiendo a esas condiciones permanentes de marginación, opacidad y agresión.